Retirees probably consider taxes, inflation or health care their biggest expenses. But there is another factor that quietly costs much more: fear.
Without the security of a regular paycheck, it’s easy to worry about running out of money in the so-called “golden years.” In fact, 64% of Americans say they are more worried about outliving their savings than dying, according to a 2025 survey by Allianz Life (1).
Although this anxiety about money is not entirely unjustified, making big financial decisions while driven by fear can be costly. The consequences can be both substantial and hard to see.
Here’s why many retirees are afraid to spend their own money — and how that hesitation can reduce their quality of life.
It is easy to assume that financial fear is inversely correlated with financial resources. In other words, the more money you have, the less you fear. However, research suggests that financial anxiety is often disconnected from actual financial capability.
Married couples over 65 with at least $100,000 in retirement savings at an average annual rate of 2.1%, according to Prudential Financial data cited by the Wall Street Journal (2). That’s far less than the commonly referred to “4% rule,” which is often cited as a rough benchmark for sustainable retirement spending.
Surprisingly, some retirees avoid retirement altogether. About 27% of retirees over age 60 with retirement accounts monitored by Vanguard did not take any withdrawals during their first five years after leaving their employer (3).
Simply put, many retirees are too afraid to spend their own hard-earned money.
For many, this extreme frugality can mean missed opportunities to spend time with family, take vacations or enjoy personal hobbies. It can also carry a real quality of life cost – though often overlooked.
Read More: The average net worth of Americans is a surprising $620,654. But it means almost nothing. Here’s the number that counts (and how it skyrockets)
A sense of fear can push many retirees to financial products that feeling safe and secure but can undermine long-term wealth if used excessively or at the wrong time.
Almost half (48%) of investors said they moved assets into more conservative investments during a market downturn, according to a 2025 Nation survey (4). In practical terms, this often means selling after prices fall — locking in losses and reducing exposure to future recoveries.
Being too conservative with your investment decisions, primarily out of fear, can be a costly mistake. You could miss out on substantial long-term growth and financial security simply because you made an impulse decision during a stock market crash.
Similarly, overpaying for certain annuities or holding large amounts of cash due to concerns about volatility can erode purchasing power — and ultimately slow portfolio growth over time.
Fortunately, there are ways to overcome this emotional response.
The antidote to emotional and fear-based investing, according to research conducted by Melissa Knoll, vice president of behavioral science at Fidelity, is a disciplined, rules-based approach (5).
Instead of relying on willpower or personal instincts, Knoll recommends using professional portfolio management or automated investment tools that help maintain consistent contributions and allocations regardless of market volatility.
For example, enrolling in automatic contributions to a 401(k) or dividend reinvestment plan (DRIP) makes investors less likely to shift assets into conservative investments during a market downturn.
Knoll also suggests checking your retirement accounts less often. Investors who frequently monitor their portfolios are less likely to accept risk and may be more prone to reduce their long-term growth.
Also, if you are checking retirement accounts less often. Investors who constantly monitor their portfolios tend to be more risk averse and more likely to make short-term decisions that could potentially reduce long-term returns.
And if you’re checking your accounts several times a week, retirement can start to feel like a second job — replacing paid work with unpaid portfolio management.
Hours spent watching financial news, reacting to market changes or studying stock charts are hours not spent with family, friends or on the activities that made retirement attractive in the first place.
Don’t let fear and short-term market noise dominate what should be your most flexible years. A time-tested plan – supported by diversification, automation, and periodic rebalancing – reduces the need for constant oversight. Set the strategy, review it occasionally, and allow time to do the heavy lifting.
Join 200,000 readers and be the first to get the best Moneywise exclusive stories and interviews — clear insight curated and delivered every week. Subscribe now.
We rely only on verified sources and credible reporting from third parties. For details, see our editorial ethics and guidelines.
Alliance (1); Wall Street Journal (2); Vanguard (3); The Nation (4); Fidelity (5).
This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.
